Nightmare 5ED 184 Fifth Edition price

Name: Nightmare 5ED 184 Fifth Edition
Brand: Magic: The Gathering
SKU: 5ed-184

Fifth Edition · released Mar 24, 1997

Market price

$1.30

As of Oct 2, 2026. Recorded daily by CardFlip.

Up 2.4% over the last 30 days
Up 9.2% over the last 90 days

Nightmare ranks 62nd of 70 priced cards in Fifth Edition, below the set's median price of $4.74.

Scan Yours Free

Price history

Price historyMarket · nonfoil

$1.30▲ $0.11 (9.2%)3M

3M low $1.19 · high $1.31 · 79 daysMay 17, 26 → Oct 2, 26

Across 139 days of daily prices, the high was $1.31 on Jul 8, 2026 and the low $1.08 on May 17, 2026. Today's price sits near the top of that range.

Is Nightmare worth selling?

Yes.

Market

$1.30

eBay Suggested

$2.71

You Keep

$1.30

A Near Mint copy of Nightmare is worth about $1.30 today. The eBay Suggested Price is $2.71; after eBay's fees and $0.75 postage you would keep about $1.30. The asking price carries the selling costs, so the sale returns the card's full value.

Near Mint: $2.71
Lightly Played: $2.49
Moderately Played: $2.26
Heavily Played: $2.05

Price your own copy →

Have a Nightmare?

Scan it with CardFlip and get today's market price and an eBay Suggested Price for your copy in seconds. The scanner reads the collector number, set code and finish off the card, so it picks out Nightmare 5ED 184, Fifth Edition, from every other printing. Your first 5 scans are free.

Scan Yours Free